A reactionary movement grew among serious music lovers: . They argued that trading a CD-quality file was the only ethical and aurally responsible way to share music. But there was one problem: no unified standard for ripping CDs accurately.
Their 1999 album How to Measure a Planet? was a double-disc masterpiece of melancholic, slow-burning alternative rock. But it was the recorded around this era that became the focus of digital purists. Part 2: Ifthenelse – The Obscure Live Release "Ifthenelse" is the key that unlocks this mystery. It is not a studio album. Instead, Ifthenelse is a rare live album and DVD package released by The Gathering in 2000 . The title plays on the binary concepts of choice and consequence, fitting the band's introspective lyrics. the gathering ifthenelse 2000 eacflac
The album was recorded during the How to Measure a Planet? tour. It captures singer Anneke van Giersbergen at her peak—her voice soaring over a mix of older tracks ("Strange Machines," "In Motion #2") and new atmospheric epics. The soundboard recording was pristine, dynamic, and uncompressed—a rarity in the loudness war era. A reactionary movement grew among serious music lovers: